I. Course Prefix/Number: PHL 204
Course Name: Environmental Ethics
Credits: 3 (3 lecture; 0 lab)
III. Course (Catalog) Description
IV. Learning Objectives
A. Explain at least four fundamentally different theories of environmental ethics and the problems that these theories address.
B. Formulate and evaluate criticisms of all the ethical theories that they study.
C. Apply theories of environmental ethics to concrete situations on the personal level, on the national level, and on the global level.
D. Adopt positions on contemporary social issues and use the ethical theory with which they agree to defend their positions both orally and in writing.
E. Evaluate the ways in which theories of environmental ethics address the needs of the diverse populations of our globalized world.
F. Exhibit values related to teamwork and collaboration, fostered by the pedagogy of shared-inquiry and critical dialogue appropriate to the humanities and philosophy.
V. Academic Integrity
• plagiarism (turning in work not written by you, or lacking proper citation),
• falsification and fabrication (lying or distorting the truth),
• helping others to cheat,
• unauthorized changes on official documents,
• pretending to be someone else or having someone else pretend to be you,
• making or accepting bribes, special favors, or threats, and
• any other behavior that violates academic integrity.
There are serious consequences to violations of the academic integrity policy. Oakton's policies and procedures provide students a fair hearing if a complaint is made against you. If you are found to have violated the policy, the minimum penalty is failure on the assignment and, a disciplinary record will be established and kept on file in the office of the Vice President for Student Affairs for a period of 3 years.
Details of the Code of Academic Conduct can be found in the Student Handbook.
VI. Sequence of Topics
I. Traditional Western Perspectives Opposing Environmental Ethics..... Selections from Lynn White and Lewis Moncrief
II. Debates overanimal rights
A. Traditional arguments maintaining that animals don't have moral standing....Selection from Immanuel Kant
B. The status ofanimals
1. Peter Singer's utilitarian defense of animals....Selection from Peter Singer
2. Tom Regan's deontological defense of animals....Selection from Tom Regan and Mary Ann Warren
3. Challenges from environmental ethicists
C. Should plants have moral standing as well?...Selection from Paul Taylor
III. Film on factory farming
IV. The Land Ethic
A. Aldo Leopold's moral vision and rejection of anthropocentrism...selection from Aldo Leopold
B. Callicott's systematization of the land ethic based on moral intuitionism....Selections from J. Baird Callicott, Michael Nelson, and Roger Paden
C. Rolston's attempted synthesis of a biocentric and an anthropocentrist ethics...Selections from Holmes Rolston and Ned Hettinger
V. Film on wolf re-introduction at Yellowstone
VI. The Challenge of Deep Ecology
A. The Eight-Point Manifesto of Naess and Sessions.
B. Naess' ethic of self-realization and his rejection of anthropocentrism....Selections from Naess, Sessions, and Devall
C. The social critique of deep ecology ...Selections from Ramachandra Guha and Richard Watson
VII. Film on global warming
VIII. Ecology and SocialJustice
A. Social Ecology....Selection from Murray Bookchin
B. Socialist Ecology...Selections from John Bellamy Foster
C. Ecofeminism........Selections from Vandana Shiva and Maria Mies
IX. Student Presentations: Case Study on Vegetarianism and Food Ethics....Selections from Garrett Hardin, William Murdoch, Mylan Engel, Mae Ho, Tristram Coffin, and Michael Fox
X. Students Presentations: Case Study on Climate Change and Environmental Racism.....Selections from the Pew Center on Gobal Climate Chiage, Stephen Gardiner, Al Gore, Maria Mies, and Alan Durning
XI. Student Presentations: Case Study on Yellowstone and the Preservation of Wildnerness and Endangered Species.....Selections from Coursepack
VII. Methods of Instruction
B. Small group work
D. Student presentations and debates
Course may be taught as face-to-face, media-based, hybrid or online course.
VIII. Course Practices Required
B. Standards for written work
F. Final Project
G. Special policies about make-up exams, late papers, or other matters of concern
H. Here is a sample:
a. Students must take four quizzes. I will distribute a brief study guide before each quiz. The quizzes will consist of questions that will require brief answers of several sentences. If you miss a quiz, you may take a make-up in the Testing Center before the next class. If you cannot make up the quiz at this point, you will need to make special arrangements with me to take an alternative quiz later in the semester. This alternative quiz will be an essay exam. They will be short answer quizzes.
b. Students must write three 5-7 page papers. Two of the papers will be on the philosophical debates, and one paper will be on a case study. In these papers, you will need to take positions and to defend these positions with philosophical arguments. You will also need to demonstrate knowledge of the assigned readings. You will receive a guide to writing philosophy papers before you begin work on your first paper. Papers must be typewritten and proofread.
c. Students willwork with a group to present an oral presentation on one of the cases.
d. Participation is very important in this class. You may earn participation points by attending class. (If you are late or must leave early, you will receive half credit for the day.) You will also need to attend at least three outside events related to the class, and you will receive one or two participation points for each of these events. We will also offer some extra credit opportunities to make up for absences. These opportunities will involve attendance at events relevant to the class such as public forums on environmental issues. I do not distinguish between excused and unexcused absences. However, if you need to be absent because of something such as religious holidays or family emergency, I will make every effort to insure that you have ways to earn extra credit that will compensate for your absence. A...34+, B....31-33, C....28-30,D....25-27
IX. Instructional Materials
X. Methods of Evaluating Student Progress
<br />A. Quizzes/Exams......40 points<br />B. Essays......40 points<br />C. Final project with oral presentation......10 points<br />D. Attendance and participation.........10 points<br />E. Grading scale: 90-100, A.......80-89, B.........70-79,C..........60-69........D
XI. Other Course Information
The Oakton Community College Catalog states:
Oakton Community College does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, creed, religion, national origin, disability, age, sex, sexual orientation, or marital status in admission to and participation in its educational programs, activities and services, or employment practices. The College does not tolerate sexual harassment or sexual assault by or of its students or employees.
In keeping with this policy of tolerance and non-discrimination, in this class all of us (myself included) should strive to listen and give careful consideration to all ideas expressed in class, especially those that are different from our own, without attacking or demeaning the people who have those views. We should also strive to avoid using insulting terms or telling offensive jokes when talking to or about individuals or groups.
Office number and office hours:
Email and website:
If you have a documented learning, psychological, or physical disability you may be entitled to reasonable academic accommodations or services. To request accommodations or services, contact the ASSIST office in the Learning Center. All students are expected to fulfill essential course requirements. The College will not waive any essential skill or requirement of a course or degree program.